WHO WILL BELL MY CONFESSIONS?
It’s the exam time…..for all the MBA aspirants its time to try and bell the CAT. So I thought why don’t I set up an aptitude question for all my friends. The question too has a touch of reality to it. I have been asked this question by many but I had no answers to it. Whenever I am asked this question either I give contradictory answers or I am in dilemma. So I thought why not take the help of my intelligent friends to come to my rescue.
In the next part of my post I am going to make some confessions and provide some information. Then I put forward a question which you all have to answer. Please do it for me. I am desperately in need of some help. Anyways without further delay lets get started.
Read the following article to answer the question below
I have three friends namely A, B, C. All my classmates know about our friendship and whenever I am asked about my friendship with these three individuals I make sure I don’t portray any one person among them to be more special or closer to me.
These are a few statements I use to describe A,B,C when my inquisitive classmates ask me:-
1. “A is a very close friend. I share a lot of things with A.”
2. “B is one of my oldest friends in college and with whom I share almost everything.”
3. “C is also a very close friend of mine with whom I like chatting for hours, enjoy spending time with C."
Yes, I almost use the same statements to describe the individuals, but the problem arises when I am asked to chose among the three. But why should I chose among them?? I treasure every friend of mine. I want all of them to be my friends. Why cant I have more than one “CLOSE TRUE FRIEND”??
Honestly speaking I did not even bother thinking on these lines till my so called close friend A raised the issue. I had managed to maintain my healthy relationship with A,B,C but today when my “close friends” question my friendship I have no answer to them. So I hope you will help me answer one of the most important questions in my life till date.
“A,B,C are my close friends”…….but did my actions justify my saying? In the next few paragraphs you will get to know more about my relationship with the three individuals. I hope these facts clear all the confusion and you all can answer my question.
1>> MY FRIEND A :-
This person has been a “friend” of mine for the last one and a half years. A always tried to help me out whenever I was in trouble. I never shared anything with A on my own, but the person compelled me to talk about my problems. A also shared a lot of things with me. Soon our friendship extended beyond the college hours, thanks to A. A called me frequently and talked to me for hours listening to what I had to say and always had a piece of advice for my welfare. Honestly speaking I never paid any heed to them.
2>> MY FRIEND B :-
B has been a very close friend indeed over the last two years in college. Honestly speaking we hardly talk to each other in college as we both have different priorities in college. But we make sure( irrespective of who takes the initiative we talk to each other almost every day over the phone.) .B might take most of the initiatives but I too play my role by calling up the person if B fails to do so. B is a true friend, I share everything on my own without any obligation or compulsion. But again I lied to B on more than one occasion without any reason. The surprising part is every time I lied to B, I was caught red handed and I had no way out. I also forget the promises I make to B but I make sure I make up for them later.
I had many quarrels with B but every time I personally called up to apologize for my mistakes and talked to B for hours. I did not want to lose a friend like B. I always tried to keep in touch with B. I would make sure we talked to each other for at least 5 minutes every night. Of course when I am in deep trouble or we have a fight I call B up innumerable times and talk to B for 2-3 hours even during the late hours.
B knows a lot of things about me which many people don’t know and I don’t want this friendship to break.But is B my closest friend?? All my readers will answer the question.
3>> MY FRIEND C :-
C is another of my friends for the last two years. I spend most of my precious time with C. C cares a lot for me.C has always been there to support me whenever I have been in problem. But there is no denying fact that I have had fair share of my problems with C. But every time C misbehaved with me fought with me on petty things I always made sure that we remain friends. Every time I thought I had enough of friendship with C and would never talk to the person my inner sole forced me to forget all the pain problems and we were again friends. Somehow I always wanted to cling on to C as a friend. When it comes to anything related to C, I tend to forget all my other friends and C is of utmost importance too understands me and I share many things with C. Spending good time together in college is not sufficient for us. We both make sure we talk to each other at night over the phone. In fact the time slot 11.00 to 11.45 pm and 6.30- 7.00 am is dedicated to my friend C. I don’t receive any other phones during that time. I may have loads of problems but still make sure we talk to each other and spend good time together.
C has been someone whom I have always banked on and I need C for my support. I am too weak today to stand on my own without C. I don’t want to hurt C. The person might be irritating some times, quite cheap in attitude but still I have become immune to all these. I am ready to sacrifice my self esteem for a friend like C.
4>> USELESS INFORMATION
The last piece of information I am going to provide you all may be immaterial but may be it highlights my level of friendship with A,B,C from my side.
i)) I remembered C’s birthday. I wished C on the birthday and even gave a small present as a token of friendship.
ii)) I remembered B’s birthday. I wished B on the birthday but did not give any present because it did not come from within myself to do so
iii) I did not remember A's birthday.
Finally I have finished confessing everything.
Now I put forward the questions:-
Q1> Arrange my friendship with A,B,C in increasing order of friendship from my side.
Q2> Am I justified in calling A,B,C all of them my close friends??
I have done the simple part, now you all have the tough job in hand to answer my questions. I eagerly wait for your reply to solve this puzzle.
Please follow the following instructions when you answer the question:-
1>> There is no time limit within which you ought answer the question ( but please make it fast for my welfare).
2>> The information does not specify the gender of any of the individuals mentioned, so when you answer the question make sure you consider all possible conditions and combination before you draw to the conclusion.
3>> Make sure when you answer the questions you think from the perspective of the author and not A,B or C.
4>> School friend( also a college friend) of the author is not a part of the above question. He is class apart and will remain a friend forever. This question is only based on the three people the author knows for the last two and a half years.
28 comments:
well well....way too complicated situation at least for me...i don't aspire for CAT anyways...
what i feel like...
wat's important to me...A is not like minded with you..bt still a frndshp can continue...somewhere there is a limit...
and i don't categorize a frnd to be into 'close' or 'best' genres....
by the way is C your Girlfriend mate??
too tough to answer ...you r the best person to decide such things and your relationship with other people. the readers of this post have no knowledge of the people concerned and hence it would be really unwise to comment on who you are better friends with ...you should be the on who decides .
But since you have asked to make a reply ... i will. Just because of the respect i have for you...
C gets most priority ..
then its B
then A
.... just let me know if i am right ........
lastly ... i would just like to say that never do anything out of compulsion....its right that you help the person when they are in trouble and ask for your advise/help... but if you can't really relate to someone... would like to avoid that person ... then make sure this person understands this ... and not be under the illusion that you are a 'good friend' .... that's where the other person is bound to feel disappointed .
cheers and do keep penning down ur thoughts ! ;-)
u worry too much...u think that what i have said was right or wrong....like that...
thats what I reckon...
better simple mathematics.....
A{B{C....
This equation or rather inequation sums it all up...
jokes apart....
What I feel is that you personally consider C to be closest...
(if she is a girl I would say first signs of falling in love!!)
but you really value his/her friendship for what ever this has to offer...care,support and a sense of belonging to a close friend...this is the form of friendship that you truly value...
You are close too B too..perhaps not close as C but dependency is all that keeps you going...someone to fall back...
And mate....Why did you continue this friendship with A if you could have made it clear earlier that you can do without a friend like him/her...Natural for A to raise a question..its almost an one sided friendship that A is burdened with...This was bound to come,sooner or later...
disclaimer:I don't know A,B or C..What I know is You..and its you who is the best judge of what will be your next course of action..Listen to your heart...
Discretion will be the better part...always...
ohh...a complicated one my friend.. but it seems normal for A to raise a question at this point.u r saying.."I am ready to sacrifice my self esteem for for a friend like C."..again..."I spend most of my precious time with C. C cares a lot for me.C has always been there to support me whenever I have been in problem."...this clearly indicates C is d closest one 2 u...
so..C...then B..then A.
it's u who can decide what's best..i just shared my thoughts as because u have asked me 2 do so..
one more thing...
never make someone a priority when he/she makes you an option...
wat i hv understd....frankly speaking there cnt b any order of fndshp as the person whom u lov is alwaz kept above fndshp n i think u love C.so C goes out of the scenario..
then B...u think him/her to be your closest fnd...u trust B a lot...
about A...i dnt think u trust A as u trust B(i dnt knw the reasn bt it apparently seems so)
Lastly i wud like to say dat u r the beter judge of the situatn as u r the person who is facing it..gv it a deep thought n i am sure dat u will overcm ur dilema..jst blv in urslf...that is wat is most imprtnt....
if anyone finds a real-life solution....the impact vl be massive...a life changing...greater than any CAT..what is in your head...pal
I won't make a long comment because I cannot judge whatever the situations are with ur frnds only through this blog...
If u talk about friendship .... as far as i am concerned, it is something mutual....and that i find only in B's case to some extent....A n C are not really Friends as far as i am concerned.....amybe U like/love C and maybe A likes/Loves U as friends or as a lover but it seems those feelings are not mutual....
Just for the sake of giving an answer i would say B C A....(based on ur prose only, and as i really don't know everything).....
a deep rooted problem indeed........
But a problem in which YOU are more involved more than either A or B or C...
A has not got justice from you when it came to friendship..neither did you give a satisfactory explanation in this brief context...
B is a valued friend of yours...and believe me it hurts losing friends like B.
C is the person in your hearts whom you have forcibly kept bye..
but the best judge of the circumstances is undoubtedly you..
and from my supposed acquaintance with C..THAT PERSON IS SUFFERING TO!!
Its vry dificult 2 measure frndship by going through some paragraph.Its a relationship which carries some emotion & spcl feelings which only u cn accumulate.........so I cn gv my opinion as a reader........bt d final judgement s upto u.
probably A s nt d dearest one...its vry clear.u r nt as much comfortable wth A AS U r wth B or C.
Both B & C r vry precious 2 u bt C wl win d race n photo finish.
The reason s dere s still some fog bwn d frndship of u & B.MAY b u r little confused sometime bt u r nt able 2 maintain d dedication of ur frndship wth B n all aspects.
In case of C u r vry much sensetive,dedicated & sharing frnd as a true frnd true frnd.
all of them r vry close frnd of u 4 sure & they all r vry much valuable gifts of god 2 u bt when u r searching 4 the superlative degree u must add the feelings of ur heart......ur emotions,ur affection 2 them.
pour d feelings of ur heart & I hope u wl surely find out d most suitable person as d 'closest frnd'of u.U r d best person 2 figure it out pal.
Well its highly intriguing the way you have elucidated the problem. I also had a glance through the others comments. Well it seems ppl feel that C is the one who u value most and possibly a partner like character. I dont think so. Firstly u have not mentioned the gender which leaves me free to explore any possibility. I however do not pay much heed to the gender.
The only thing I would say is that A is a friend who does not complain about you nt paying enuf attention as a friend should not. A tries to help u wen u need. Its another matter that u dont do the same. May be ur attitude towards A is because u have taken him or her for granted. I hereby make a very POWERFUL comment by saying that A is the friend u r closest to. Yes U R Closest to A. Since u do not worry that A might go away in any case, A is always there for you, u tend to ignore him/her a bit. U want to cling on to B and C cos u fear they might nt turn back to you if u do not talk to them regularly. Tho u say theres no obligation on ur part but still u make sure that u call them up and keep i tuch. Its kind of Superficial to me. U want to portray a gr8 bonding towards them. However u have admitted in the beginning of ur article that u treasure ABC equally. Y then do u think u try and obligatorily keep in tuch wid b and C and nt A. B cos u know A will never leave u. A is always there for u. Ur relation wid A is nt very formal but deeply within very binding. I wud rather say A has the partner like qualities.
This judgement was purely based on ur facts and from ur side. Wat A and the others think do not matter.
Ranking: - A > B > C
U r nt justified in callin them equal friends but u would luv to think they are. That is y u kip sayin that. B and C do not have as much of place or share of ur confidence as A else u wudnt have ignored A that much. U want to bliv B and C are there equally for u because B and C have some sort of glamour(not just petty looks/physiques but personality) the company of which u luv to have.
i like the above point ...certainly v v valid ....
hey ths is disha first...dnt no u n dnt no A,B,C eithr....
bt stil ur jus amazing n extremely innovative way of presentation of ur prob...really makes me 1st appreciate the beauty with whch u have woven ths problem...n thn compels me 2 answer
m sory.......with due respect to the content...mah appreciation dsnt trivialize ur prob...
truly speaking...i have literally solved thousands of mcqs...n puzzles....cz i really love it..had it been a CAT prob i wud hav solved it or atleast cud have given a shot 4 sure................evn if i dnt no ne of the persons involved in it...u no...the data is mr than sufficient to answer the query cz u have touched evry minute aspect...
yeah the difference btwn cat problems n ths problem is dat thr is involvement of variable factors in both..bt in ur case all these factors r human beings having difffernt psychologies,diff facets of personalities.........
n only ths diff actually lands me in failure in reaching to a set ans to ths question....
i dnt underatnd y we wana priotize n set ranking to frndshps...n relations...we all very complex beings having various facets to our personality.....n evry frnd with all his o her flaws n gud things touches n fulfills the neeed of sm aspect of our personality....they can nvr be ranked......
eg if asked a question...rank btwn ur spouse n ur mom???cn ths question be evr answered???i dnt think so........we love both of thm bt in a diffrnt manner.....ths relationshp altogether have diffrnt planes.........
evrybdy else has talked bout gender thing..........bt i think evn dat is immaterial.....nobdy can be replaced......itz mah thot.....i m 1st tym posting a cmmnt....i jus hope dat u r nt offended by ne statement........
well,well..ths is a very complicatd nd sensitive issue..to cmmnt fr..as far as my knowledge goes i thnk tht u shld nt cmpare among ur frnds..its ur feelngs, tht u cnt reasonize..i feel tht C shld be a gvn a little mre attntn..nd the remainn its PERFECT, DUDE..
WEll as FAr as YOUR posts ARE concerned i dont agree...C might be very good C,YOU might have weaknesses for c but lemme tell you dude ...its C on whom you depend and as for you mentioned FRiend...i would say oyu should love a friend care for a friend but NEVER depend on him..../her....DUDE time changes your LOVE TOwards YOUr parents this is just a friend...WAt if YOU barr friendship with everyone but c AND then C ceases to be friends with you....
IN that CAse A has all the qualities that C has but then YOU dont have a chance to acknowledge his friendship damn it your so damn dependant on C......be FRiends With C but MAke A your closest in that Way you will never get hurt
see ur artical highlights dat A is not a special frnd of u...u wanna continue d relation with A in a normal way bt A wants u else dan dat.....now come B...... he is lyk a very good frnd of u and both of u share a lot thinghs.........there is nothing else dan dat.....bt i guess dat C is a very special frnd of u ......so in case of giving the priorities i think C gets more than B and A gets lesser than B ......bt why r u thinkin so much of dat.....dont be confused and continue d relations or relation in its normal way.....
it is very difficult to explain....
but i think 1.C then 2.B and then 3.A
C is very close to you..perhaps the closest one..
B is also close. but not so important to you like C.
and in case of A, i think you want to avoid A.
achha....it seems A,B,C represent three kinds of ur classmates u've tried to analyze with regard to ur feedback to them,i think they r not individuals.
Ok the 1st one A is pretty much interested to share everything of him/her with u but u rn't n u only want to just formalize this kind of relationship which A take vry seriously.
Next comes B with whom u r quite implicit while sharing all of urs n yet u sometimes lie to B.B always plays the role of neutralizer in petty misunderstandings n u can't hide the truth 4m B.
next n last 1 is C without whom u think u r incomplete n
that person is ur highest priority
when the matter of reliability n might b some kind of relieving accompany comes but with the attitude of C sometimes pesky 2 u.but u lied to c n forget his/her budday n u r really remorseful bout what u were of C sometime.
well to conclude.....i think ur friendship with these 3 r on the verge of final judgement ok according to me u were n u r n u should b a true friend of B.
in case of A u should b vry clear 2 him/her bout how u really wanna b to him/her instead of doing opposing efforts of trying 2 b a good friend as well as avoiding A.
n finally u might b trying 2 rewind the tapes in case of C but it seems 2 me rolling back may b quite tough 4 u but i won't discourage u.u should try.
now ma final conclusion is the increasing order should b B>C>A.
n the justification comes only 4 B while calling him/her a true n close friend of urs.
i guess dat C is a very special frnd of u.bt again telling u dat its vry difficult 2 divide dis three.In case of C u r vry much sensetive,dedicated & emotional.
bt side by side u can't also ignore
A & B as one is uor EYES & d another is uor EARS.So if one is absent,u r crippled.
Bt to be specific.............
C IS UOR HEART!!!!!!!!!!
by the way,will u plz tell me one thing dat is C your Girlfriend????
:) :) :) :) :) :)
well, let's see. it's the most utterly confusing post i have ever seen on a personal blog. u r choked sutirtha.....
but..anyhow...jokes apart.let's come to the point.....
I'm not supposed to take names here, but I'm dying to do so. guess, I'll have to restrain from that.
A B C, - the choice of codenames for your friends is very well thought. i mean. it's not exactly numerical...which otherwise would have diverted me into thinking that their "closeness" to you is already numbered. but then again there is a subtle link to numbers in alphabets too.
and most importantly, the way u have, i should say, "tried to divert us into an "almost" rhetorical conclusion" by very carefully using the "useless information" part is very commendable.
that's very tricky. quite a trick u have done there buddy. it's an absolute red herring. only created to divert the comments to some pre defined conclusion.
but I'll be very frank here and I'll be absolutely true.
here's what i think-
- there is no distinction between your three friends.....i say it again --
"A B C are absolutely on the same line as far as your closeness to them is concerned"..
And precisely there is no ranking from your part. but there is an alter ego playing behind this question u have raised. u have not ranked them, it's true, but at the same time, the very fact that u have not ranked them, together with the subtle fluctuations of mood and your behavior towards them at different times, have been bugging you for quite some time and has made u think that perhaps there indeed is a ranking between these three friends of yours. but you, as confused as ever, are feeling guilty that you have to rank so dear friends of yours, friends that have always been so close to your heart. so what do you do?. you create a topic and ask all your friends to do this ranking on your behalf. this is exactly what has happened. in your mind, in your heart, there is no difference between your friends and you look at then with equal love from your part. but u have realized that that this is not p[possible for you to continue for long. the time, as you have realized, to choose among your friends, has come. a very hard time, i know. cause i have been through such times.
but here is my advice to you buddy,-- don't do this. even if the answers you get here, help you to create a distinction between your so dear friends, just don't do it. this thing will bug you forever. you'll forever feel guilty.
you have provided a wonderful light at the end of the path for yourself. it is the useless information that everybody would use to create the ranking among A,B,C. please consider that as really "useless" information. just presenting a gift to someone doesn't make a good friendship better, neither does forgetting a birthday make it worse.
friendship is beyond betterment or worsening. that's what it should always be. it should be omnipresent, not transient. some superfluous actions should not guide this bond of friendship.
they are all dear friends, and that's what they should always be.
enough saying, let's have a toast to your friendships to A B and C.
i)C>B>A....................
ii)u can cal b n c as ur close frnds bt dnt evn thnk f dat in case f A................
please dont mind, but i think u r wasting ur time buddy! u have just 1n1/2 yrs left,u shud be living these momnts to d fullest in place of deciding who ur closest frnd is.u shud b happy tht u have close frnds.is tht not enuf? y do u wnt 2 distance 2 of ur frnz by choosing 1 out of 3 as ur closest frnz? in a way r u too nt questionin ur frndshp?
d questions tht u've asked, if u want answers to them, search for them inside u.im sure u have all ur answers n just in case u dont get ne answer, knw tht u r lucky not to knw thm.
It's not only a complicated situation for u bt also a complicated situation for me to answer these questions,,well jokes apart.Newaz the answer to ur 1st question is obviously C>>B>>A.Now it may sound silly to u dat i hav categorized dem in increasing order of friendship frm ur side.Coz i feel dere cn b only 1 or 2 friend wid whm u cn share eveything(everything means each and every small things of ur life like any family probs or any non veg matters).Bt based on da confessions u hv stated here it is C wid whom u share everything irrespective of whether he/she is sharing anything wid u coz u feel most comfortable wid C and then wid B to some extent.From the sharing perspective B then comes next to C and lastly comes A.
Now my answer to ur 2nd question is-u cant call any of them as ur close friend...coz i feel any relationship has to be 2 sided for dat relationship to continue.Now ur relationship wid A,B and C are 1 sided.The proof to my quote is u care for C a lot bt C does'nt for u dat much and u cant disagree dat fact.Now the same thing is with B,the only difference is that B do use to pay some heed and importance to u.Bt on the contrary A do use to pay heed to u whenever u were in trouble bt it was u who did'nt care for him/her.
Now i'm eager to ask u 1 question
On ur birthday among A,B and C who wished u and who gave u a birthday present??
Frst of all,U r the bst person to gve ansrs to thse questns,no one else.Because,I think it will vary frm man to man.Ur process of thght cann’t be sme with anyone else.But ya,if u ask me,from ur sde C is the closest.And then comes B,A respectively.And u r nt wrng to say C or B ur clse frnd.But never A.
What u hv tld abt A,frm that I thnk A sure gonna b a gal.And I blv she mst hve sme spcl flngs fr u.But u don’t hve.So u cann’t say A , a close frnd.A always try to be close to u,but u hve avoided alwys. So it is not impossble tht A gets frustrated,specially if A is a gal.I thnk that’s the reason why A hve asked u abt cmprsn of closeness.And u shld make clear evrythng to A as soon as possible,bfre it bcmes so lte.
In case of B,u share smethng what is needed mst in a strng frndshp.I mean,the frndshp is nvr one-sided.It is perfectly balanced.
But C is someone who is closest to u,atlst from ur sde.And what I feel,U r in LOVE with C.I cann’t say if C is also or nt.But u shld try to know what C feels fr u.Bcse it may b possible tht C has no spcl flngs abt u.If she also loves u ,then bst of lck fr ur love.But if nt,thn try to frgt C as soon as possible.Bcse once,u ll strt to love someone deeply,u can nvr tke her as jst frnd.
Well well,offcourse it is complicated...but as I see it,to solve problems that are difficult in nature we got to break it simple parts...The way I look at it is C is the authors closest friend since I get the feeling that the author have more fights with C than any other frnds AND I always believe that the ones that u fight the most are ur closest frnds and also the author felt an inner urge to sought out matter everytime they had fights which is noteworthy....For me the choise is very difficult btw A and B..But If I am forced to make a decision then I would say that A is closer frnd of the author than B.Well I'm sorry that I won't be able to give any reason for this choise because some things are never thought of...they are just felt...so that's it..............I will stick to my choise even if you say I am wrong b'cos that's how I am..
@ all the readers of my blog till date.................
Thanx a ton for wasting ur precious time and takng the trouble to cmmnt on my post.......i appreciate all ur cmmnts and it has been really hlpful.
To be honest the post has no specific answer because i myslf donot knw the answer.......it is not a stry about myslf.........infact i am A in the story....i write the entire post frm the perspective of a person who demarcated between A,B,c and there lies the twist in the tale.......
the comments really helpd me realise wat i shud have realsied myslf.........A" was never a frnd"---just an obligation for the concrnd person.......i am happy today when i read--"A was never ur friend" and feel sad at the same time when i realise i was so late in realisng the true facts.......
thnk u frnds who made me realise the relaity and i promise to abide by ur verdict.......i hope i can rely on all of u in future too when i am need..............thnx a lot to all
last but not the least thnx to my FRIEND who took the pain of maintaining the obligation for 2 and hlf yrs.........thanx a lot........wish u all the luck and hope u r happy with B and C...
December 24, 2008 2:52 PM
With out know their gender its difficult to answer..... well if they are all guys than u must go to a doctor . u are not well, why would a guy talk to another guy for hours in the night.... I wish from deep inside from my heart that A,B and c all are girls.... if they are girls than i would say its A,C,B
A is first beacuse you take him for granted you know she is there wheather u care for her or not.... and you will realished it when she wont be there for you.... people whom we love the most we take them for granted.for example (Mom).
Than its c beacuse she takes you for granted she knows you will be there for her .
B is the last, U think u care for her but in reality u dont.... so dude its A,C,B......
I feel C is really a very close friend (from the perspective of the author), and then come B and A.
Friendship cannot be gauged by the number of minutes you talk over the phone, and surely not by remembering birthdays (I can assure you this, from my personal experience). There are 'A's in all of our lives, and they really hold a special position at times of need. And I would like to concur with one of the views already expressed by a friend, and that is, A had just been taken for granted by the author, and maybe that only made you feel like asking who among A, B and C are really close friends to the author. But people are taken for granted only when the other person knows him/her to be so dear that the latter will always be there by his/her side.
Post a Comment